Of all the topics I have written about in the column, none has
stimulated more reader response than anal furunculosis; letters,
telephone calls, e-mails and even a couple of comments to me from
some people at shows.
To date all the
dogs involved have been GSDs with an age range of under one year to
over 10 years. The exception is a 10 years old Pembroke Corgi
bitch, apparently she developed the problem early this year. The
owner e-mailed me to comment that her vet, who has been in practice
for over thirty years has never seen this condition “in a bobtail
before.” I would tend to agree. I remember one of the treatments
advocated about forty years ago was amputation of the tail of the
GSD because it was considered that with the increasing angulation
seen in the breed, the close lying tail prevented air circulation
around the perineal area and in consequence allowed the infection to
spread.
This particular
dog is interesting because the owner’s case history is absolutely
typical even if the breed is anything but so. I would certainly
agree with her veterinary surgeon. I have never seen a case of anal
furunculosis in a Corgi but if one accepts that the condition is
immune mediated in origin there is really no reason why Corgis
should not be affected just like many other breeds.
The progress of
the disease in this dog is interesting and has obviously been
carefully recorded by the owner. Initially it was noted that the
anal region appeared wet and on investigation the owner found the
skin around the anus was red. This was then followed by the
fistulous tracts which appeared first on one side and then the
other. It is often at the red and wet stage that veterinary surgeons
will pick up early signs of the condition, often when the dog is
presented for routine vaccination, etc. In this particular case
the dog was prescribed Cyclosporine without delay. The owner
mentions it cost £93 for thirty capsules. The original dose was two
50 mg capsules per day. As I mentioned in the previous article the
response was little short of dramatic and the dose was soon reduced
to just one capsule a day. This particular dog does not appear to be
showing other problems such as bowel syndrome and this may be due in
part to the fact that she was fed a normal diet of tripe and
wholemeal biscuit.
Obviously some of
the cases that have been reported to me in GSDs have clearly had a
multiplicity of problems including most commonly IBD (Inflammatory
Bowel Disease) Treatment of the bowel problem as well as the anal
furunculosis is imperative but this of course increases the cost to
the owner since the provision of special diets, be they commercial
or home prepared inevitably involves extra cost, the cost of which
in the case of suspected dietary allergy can be lifelong.
From your response
one factor stands out, Cyclosporine although frighteningly
expensive, nonetheless evokes a better response than any of the
other methods of treatment in anal furunculosis that are currently
practised.
These results have
been in accordance with the figures quoted by Dr Bryden Stanley in
her presentation at BSAVA congress in April. She reported results
using Cyclosporine of 100% improvement in clinical signs with an
80-8=90% of resolution of lesions.
In the studies
quoted long term results were also far more encouraging than those
she quoted with other methods of treatment (60-90%). With
Cyclosporine recurrence is quoted at 30-50%. This also appears to
be associated in the main with anal sac problems. I am surprised
under the circumstances that anal sacs are not removed earlier in
the disease. Considering the cost of Cyclosporine, operation to
remove the anal sacs would be very cost effective it is reduced the
need to repeat the courses of Cyclosporine which seems to be the
trend according to my correspondents.
The good news is,
of course, this work does appear to indicate that the dose of
Cyclosporine can be reduced by up to 75% with the introduction of
another drug, Ketaconozole, which prevents the breakdown of
Cyclosporine by the liver and thus a much lower dose can be used.
Ketaconozole is
itself an expensive drug but only approximately one third the cost
of Cyclosporine. Thus overall a combination of the two drugs can
become almost affordable.
Therefore the
outlook is a lot better than it ever has been for dogs with anal
furunculosis but although the initial short term results of
Cyclosporine appear little short of miraculous be forewarned that
relapses can and do occur, necessitating further courses of the
drug. Furthermore it does appear that even with the initial
dramatic improvement the Cyclosporine should nevertheless be
continued for three to four months otherwise relapses are likely to
occur. However if these do occur the lesions can be treated far more
effectively by surgical means and if the anal sacs are removed as
soon as possible you have then done everything possible to ensure
this awful condition is kept in check.
One final word, as
a result of all the research I have undertaken into this condition
particularly recently, I am more than convinced than ever that if I
decide to enquire a German Shepherd Dog I would endeavour to secure
the highest level of pet health insurance that I could afford!
© Trevor Turner –
jean.trevor@virgin.net
15th
June 2003.